Rabbi Mark Asher Goodman
  • Home
  • About
  • Writings
  • Audio
  • Video
  • Media Coverage
  • Soccer Rabbi

Human Autonomy should be a Basic Right

2/9/2025

0 Comments

 
Dvar Torah Beshallach 5785
​

I generally prefer to select my own sermon topics from the myriad of interesting possibilities in the weekly parsha. But alas, this week is not one of those weeks, because you all know that the president made a policy statement this week in a joint press conference with Bibi Netanyahu about the future of Gaza. And so we have to talk about it.
I don’t think you missed it, because how could you, but if you missed the announcement, President Trump said several things. First, that Palestinians should be relocated to Egypt and Jordan. Second, that the United States will come in and take over Gaza. Third, that we will QUOTE “own it”, and fourth that Gaza would be redeveloped into the Riviera of the Mediterranean.

The reaction was swift and unforgiving. Most people saw it either as magical thinking, or wildly impractical, or blatantly against international law, or wholly unjust and immoral. I will say one nice thing about the plan, which is that it is an actual plan. Before President Trump proposed his idea, nobody really had a plan for who would oversee Gaza in the near term, or who would rebuild it. So at least it’s a plan.

The proposal is part of what we have come to see as the Trumpian world view, and that is land is a valuable asset, while people, particularly foreign people, are a liability. Gaza is simply 141 square miles of empty potential, waiting to be transformed into golf courses and Mar a Lago - Rafah. To further this idea, Trump believes that peoples compete for resources. That every dollar sent to Mexico for avocados comes out of the pockets of California avocado growers, that every undocumented immigrant in the US is taking a job away from an unemployed American. 

Trump is, in this respect, a man who had a very successful theory on one aspect of the economy, and now applies that theory to everything in a very ‘if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail’ approach to the universe. Trump knows how to develop hundreds of acres of bare land into a golf course. But golf courses are a very specific type of investment - there’s a lot of empty land, some very rich men wandering around paying lots of money to chase a little dimpled ball, and relatively few employees needed to keep the thing going. Trump sees rubble and imagines a golf course. Only, golf courses have no people on them, except the very rich. So Trump says ‘ok, everybody who isn’t very rich can go to Jordan or Egypt. Only, of course, Jordan and Egypt didn’t agree to that. This is the one part of Trump’s calculus I don’t really understand. Here’s a man who doesn’t like foreign nationals who are applying for residency in this country and wants to use the US Army to detain and deport 2 million of them, but he looks at the heads of state of Jordan and Egypt and says to them ‘you should take 2 million foreign nationals into your countries permanently.’ I don’t really follow the logic, other than Trump believing that its totally reasonable to decide to uproot and relocate people anywhere in the world, as long as that place isn’t the United States of America. I also don’t really even follow the logic of redeveloping Gaza, which is 9,000 miles away, when Haiti, a tropical nation only 150 miles away, is in desperate need of aid and redevelopment.

The reason the world, including much of the American Jewish community, reacted so negatively to this proposal is the first step in the effort to redevelop Gaza is the removal of all the residents. I think Trump thinks that the Palestinians will all take a second passport in Jordan and Egypt, and live there for a few years until his contractors have finished building the each resorts and the golf courses, and then they’ll come back to Gaza and work as waiters and line chefs and Middle East peace will flourish. 

The problem with the thinking is that the two people most involved in this situation, the Israelis and the Palestinians, both have deep histories with displacement and relocation, and neither of them have any good memories of it. For Palestinians, many of them were displaced to Gaza and the West Bank in 1948, and many have been hoping to return for 77 years now. For Israelis, they were a stateless people for 2000 years, and at the conclusion of the Holocaust in Europe in 1945, they were unable to return home. My own grandmother left her home town of Rakov in 1943, never to return again. Not only that, but her bitterness and anguish over the pain of the injustices done to her and her whole family were so deep that she has told her children and her grandchildren to never return to Poland again as long as we live. And none of us ever has. That’s three generations of intergenerational bitterness in my family towards people in a country that I’ve never even been to.

Every one of us in this room and on zoom has Jewish relatives who came to this country on a boat or a plane because they were unwelcome or cast out of some other place, and so they created a new home for themselves here in this country. Most people that leave home do so because they have little or no other options. 

This is the part of the Gaza redevelopment plan that Trump, and some Israelis, are missing. And by the way, the Israeli newspaper Maariv did a survey and found this week that 78% of Israelis polled backed the plan to expel Palestinians from Gaza. What they forget is that the core of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is about the feeling of being forced off your land to begin with. I’m not even sure its about one specific Palestinian families desire to return to one specific house in Jaffa or Netzeret, but rather the knowledge that they were forced to leave a place and now have no right to choose where or whether they can return. People want the free agency to go places and live their lives with dignity and respect. They do not want another people to decide what is best for them.

And of course we know this lesson all too well as Jews, because it is the essence of the story of the Exodus. Pharaoh wanted to control all the Israelites - to determine their fates, to rule over them and deny them the free will of free people. It is a frequent misconception that the original demand of the Israelites was to go out from slavery and leave Egypt and travel to Israel and be a free people. That is, actually, not at all what the Israelites asked for. Two weeks ago, in Parshat Shemot, chapter 5, we read the following:
וְאַחַר בָּאוּ מֹשֶׁה וְאַהֲרֹן וַיֹּאמְרוּ אֶל־פַּרְעֹה כֹּה־אָמַר יְהֹוָה אֱלֹהֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל שַׁלַּח אֶת־עַמִּי וְיָחֹגּוּ לִי בַּמִּדְבָּר׃
Afterward Moses and Aaron went and said to Pharaoh, “Thus says יהוה, the God of Israel: Let My people go that they may celebrate a festival for Me in the wilderness.”

But Pharaoh said, “Who is Adonai that I should heed him and let Israel go? I do not know Adonai, nor will I let Israel go.”

In other words, the Israelites weren’t demanding that they cease being slaves and be given total freedom. They were only asking for a couple days off in the desert. They wanted a modicum of control of their own lives, and Pharaoh said no. The problem here is not that the Israelites want total self determination. The problem is that denying them any semblance of control over their lives is intolerable. Ultimately, Pharaoh refuses to give them any self-determination, and so God, Moses, and Aaron begin asserting their demand for rights more and more, and finally it results in the people completely going free from under Pharaoh’s thumb.

‘Gee that’s interesting rabbi’, you may say to yourself. ‘But what does it mean going forward for Israel and the Jewish people?’ The answer is a resounding ‘I don’t know.’ At high holidays I gave a sermon about two soccer teams in which the thesis was ‘these two peoples are interdependent, and their futures are tied together.’ And I still believe that. In contrast, the proposal to simply remove Palestinians from Gaza as a solution is the opposite of interdependence - it is instead radical amputation - it proposes that Jews cannot live with Palestinians and therefore permanent relocation and racial and religious separation are the only solution. That would be a very dangerous suggestion because of what it would mean for the rest of Israeli society. If Israel can’t figure out a way to live alongside Palestinian society in Gaza, can it live alongside Palestinians in the West Bank, who enter and exit Israel for work every day? Can it live with the 21% of the population that are Israeli Arabs, who are clustered in predominantly Arab cities like Natzeret and Umm Al Fahm and Abu Snan and Sachnin.
One of the challenges of the Trump plan is that it feels like empty words. Israelis fought a war that demolished 70% of the buildings in Gaza, but now someone else claims they’re going to clean up the mess. To that end, I can see why so many Israelis like Trumps plan - because if it were to come to pass, Israelis don’t have to provide security , or provide food aid, or rebuild the mess. The Americans will do it. And that sounds fairly unlikely to me. I could see a way forward in which the US, the EU, Saudi Arabia, the Palestinian Authority, and Israel all collaborate to rebuild Gaza together. Perhaps they could even placate Donald Trump by letting the Army Corps of Engineers build him a beachfront resort. Or maybe a coalition of states rebuilding together sounds just as improbable as Trump building golf courses in Rafah. I concede that maybe I’m too optimistic.

In our Torah, God tells the Israelites that God will split the sea and take them out of Egypt. But, famously, in a midrash in the Talmud, the rabbis tell us that none of the Israelites were brave enough to enter the water. And then Nachshon Ben Amminidav walked in, and the sea parted after him. In other words, yes God will help you cross the sea. But you have to walk into it. You have to put one foot in front of the other. There is no quick and easy solution after the war for Israel and Gaza. The solution for both will involve either increased cooperation and collaboration that will slowly, over a generation, lead to the first steps towards mutual trust, or just another generation in the wilderness of animosity.
The parsha this week, beshallach, includes the song of the seas, which appears in the morning shacharit prayer every single day of the year without fail. It has one sentence that always gives me pause - Adonai Ish Milchamah - Adonai Shemo - God is a man of war, Adonai is God’s name. The implication could be that God was with Israel in their battle with Pharaoh, although to be honest, there was no battle with Pharoah - the Israelites ran and God closed the sea on them. But in general, the sentiment is appreciated - when you find yourself in combat, when you are in a foxhole, God is with you. 

After the battle, when it’s time to clean up, though, the responsibility to rebuild isn’t on God, but upon humans. In a section of our prayerbook we read on shabbat right after ein keloheinu, or realistically, a section we skip almost every week, it says the following:

אָמַר רַבִּי אֶלְעָזָר אָמַר רַבִּי חֲנִינָא: תַּלְמִידֵי חֲכָמִים מַרְבִּים שָׁלוֹם בָּעוֹלָם, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר: ״וְכׇל בָּנַיִךְ לִמּוּדֵי ה׳ וְרַב שְׁלוֹם בָּנָיִךְ״.
Rabbi Elazar said that Rabbi Ḥanina said: Torah scholars increase peace in the world, as it is said: “And all your children [banayikh] shall be taught of the Lord, and great shall be the peace of your children” (Isaiah 54:13). If all the children of Israel are taught of the Lord, there will be peace for all.
אַל תִּקְרֵי ״בָּנָיִךְ״ אֶלָּא ״בּוֹנָיִךְ״.
The Sages interpreted this verse homiletically: Do not read your children [banayikh], but your builders [bonayikh]. Torah scholars are those who build peace for their generation. 

God may be an ish milchamah, a man of war, but Torah scholars are the builders, or the rebuilders. We are called on to build literally, and by building literally, our tradition tells us ‘great will be the peace of your children.’ So I welcome the idea of turning Gaza into the riviera of the middle east. But you can’t solve past injustices by committing a host of brand new ones. It must be that the long, slow process of rebuilding be done by many people and together, and that the main goal of any construction projects be in solving a generational refugee problem rather than creating a brand new one yet again.




0 Comments

It’s not Politics. It’s Morality. And Life.

1/24/2025

1 Comment

 
Picture

It’s not Politics. It’s Morality. And Life.

Occasionally we talk in synagogue about spicy topics in which folks have a difference of opinions. We hold the space for slightly uncomfortable discussions. And not everyone likes when I frame things in this manner. Over the course of my 19 year career, folks have sometimes said “I don’t like it when the rabbi talks politics from the bimah”. (Yes, I know you all think I’m so young! Take a look at my beard, though, and you’ll notice there’s a lot of grey in there.)

And it’s true that politics doesn’t belong on the bimah. Candidates for office should vye for your vote without using the sensitive and personal heartstrings of religion to influence you. Rabbis and pastors should not become shills for a current politician with promises that might, for the moment, align with what a faith teaches.


But morals belong on the bimah. And life belongs on the bimah. Otherwise, it’s just empty words.

Our tradition asks us, over and over and over again, to be moral, just, and compassionate. “Care for the foreigner, the orphan, and the widow.” “Every person was created in the image of God.” “Do not pervert justice.” “Justice, justice shall you pursue.” “Love your neighbor as yourself.” “Open, open your hand to the needy.” “The life of a mother precedes the life of her unborn fetus.” Lift up the poor and set free the captive.” “May the One who makes peace in heavens make peace on earth.” “We must build a world of lovingkindness.” “Do not oppress the stranger, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt.” These are core tenets of our religion.

And so when we talk in synagogue about our morals, and about life: about immigrant expulsion; about protecting and affirming Trans, Lesbian, and Gay individuals; about health care for low-income folks; about women’s right to bodily autonomy; about war in Gaza ; about the priority of freeing hostages; about income inequality or tax policy for the rich; about the importance of education and libraries and universities; about free speech and freedom or religion; we are speaking Torah. We are affirming the 5,000 year old values of our people. 

And so if it just so happens that the morals and values we affirm in our synagogues run counter to the things that politicians say or push through the legislative or executive branch, oh well. We cannot – we should not – we will not – apologize for practicing our beliefs, while individuals with primary motives of self-interest espouse other, anti-religious anti-morality. When some pundit proclaims the words of compassion and justice uttered by a brilliant spiritual leader like Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde are ‘woke’, we should just chuckle and shake our heads. 

Go ahead. Call us ‘woke’.  I assure you, in the long history of our people, we have certainly been called much worse – and primarily because we have always been a voice for right and humanity in times when those principles were decidedly unpopular.

So if we talk about current events and the politics of the day at synagogue over the coming months and years, and we will, keep your focus. Our religion compels us to consider others needs before our own in a dozen specific and critical ways. Just because the political winds are blowing in a different direction doesn’t mean we will  grow mute in the face of injustice and immorality. 

Our God is just and compassionate.  Torah is our focus. Nothing can or should convince us otherwise.

1 Comment

Eulogy for Marilyn Stern

1/21/2025

0 Comments

 
Hesped Marilyn Stern

As some of you may know, each Wednesday morning for the past six years, I had the distinct pleasure of teaching Marilyn Stern in a class we called ‘Life and Text’. I say ‘we’ here because Marilyn was one of the original members of class that helped decide the format and even the name of the class. The class is ostensibly a very standard Jewish offering you will find in many synagogues across the globe; a parshat hashavua class on the weekly reading in the Hebrew Bible. But of course, our class is also a gathering space and a support group, a social club, a place for uplift and moral and spiritual exploration, and an education for both the students and the teacher in the ways and methods of Hassidic philosophy. 

But Marilyn, in her very Marilyn way, made the class into something greater, both for her and for all of us. And in that she became, on many occasions, my teacher.

She had two very persistent approaches to the class. 

The first was as textual critic. A spiritual reading of a biblical text is typically a meditation and an exploration to be pondered and appreciated. But on occasion, not always, but occasionally, Marilyn would raise her hand in the dark wood paneling of our conference room on the second floor of Beth Shalom and say plainly “I have a problem with this text.” And then she would pick apart why the commentator was in error for understanding a verse a certain way or by utilizing a misshapen or wonky type of logic. If it didn’t ring true, or it wasn’t elegant, or was too simplistic, then Marilyn would critique it, like any type of literature, as if this long dead Polish spiritual master was like any other student in her classroom: one who received a B on the assigned essay, but needed proper direction as to how it could be improved.

The second was as a grammatical and linguistic stickler. Every Hassidic text in our class is from a group of 18th and 19th century Eastern European rabbis who may or may not have been an adept writer; and they are all translated by me. So when Marilyn would say “That’s not the right word” or “That’s not how that word should used”, I could never tell if Marilyn was critiquing the 18th century rabbi, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl, or critiquing my inelegant translation of Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl. This was Marilyn, in her element. She wanted the language to be precise and clean, and she wanted to push you to be your best. And even in retirement, she was forever and always, first and foremost, a teacher, and proud of it.

Marilyn Stern was born March 12, 1949, in Rochester, NY. She attended Skidmore College for undergraduate, and then Boston University and Boston College for advanced degrees in Broadcasting & Film, and English, and Drama. She had a lifelong passion for music, and was an accomplished singer. She taught and was an administrator at Maimonides High School in Brookline and Wentworth Institute of Technology in Jamaica Plain, where she had what was the sometimes thankless task of demonstrating the beauty of literature and fiction to future engineers, scientists, and mathematicians. From 1981 until her retirement in 2017, she set herself to the task of convincing her students of the value of writing, and of words.

While she was getting her degrees and at the outset of her teaching career, she was also a loving and committed mother, first to Matthew, who came along in 1978, and then Melissa, who was born in 1981. Her two children emphasized that their mother took pains to carve out a teaching schedule that still allowed her to pick up the kids at school and to make dinner and be with her children, even if that meant sometimes then rushing back out the door for an evening class.

Marilyn’s love for the written word was impressed upon Matthew and Melissa. They were allowed and encouraged to read anything and everything. Toys she wasn’t that keen on buying, it seemed, but Matthew and Melissa never wanted for reading material. Melissa recounted that as a child she liked the Sweet Valley High series of books, and one day Marilyn happened upon a garage sale with the entire series for sale. She bought them all and brought them home.

Marilyn also loved music, and singing, and perhaps in another life that might have been her profession. She studied in a conservancy and was a proud member of the Hebrew chorale Zamir in Boston for many years. Her daughter recounted that when she was in synagogue and sang along with the service or the cantor, heads would turn from all the surrounding rows to see who it was with the big booming, professionally trained voice.

She instilled in her children a strong moral compass. She was honest and fair, and as the child of a bookkeeper, Matthew noted, she made sure that her income taxes were paid exactly as they should be, taken no undue deductions or tax breaks.

She cared deeply about the Jewish value of hachnasat orchim, of hosting guests. Her table at passover was full to overflowing. Melissa recounted that their home in Needham once hosted 37 people for dinner, all to taste the many delicious things that Marilyn cooked. 

Marilyn was also a great cook, something she proudly inherited from her mother, although her children implied that Marilyn’s mother’s baking skills passed to her sister, Ellen. Her tzimmes, and her blackened chicken wings, and her chicken soup , especially her chicken soup, were exceptional and something that everybody looked forward to. One of the funny paradoxes, however, of Marilyn’s chicken soup is that it had no written recipe. Matthew and Melissa told me that it was a pinch of this and dash of that, and it always was fantastic, but there wasn’t a precise recipe that she following. This is, I might note, a little like writing, in that although precision is deeply important, there isn’t an exact science to it, and every written work is going to be a little different from the last. Writing, and cooking, and singing - are all a nice microcosm of living. They are composed of the somewhat equal parts art, and science, and magic, and precision, and experimentation.

When Marilyn retired in 2017, she chose to move to Pittsburgh to be near her youngest two grandchildren, Moses and Lillith and she was the most devoted, most loving grandparent to them and before that to Matthew’s two children, Ida and Abbie. During the Covid pandemic she took care of Moses and Lillith while Melissa and Mark were working as essential workers. Our class continued on Zoom, and every once in a while Marilyn would interrupt a thought on a text by Simcha Bunim of Peshisecha with asking Mo if he wanted more lunch. Marilyn’s health was sensitive at that time, but her devotion to her grandchildren was so absolute that her caring for them was a foregone conclusion even though it posed some risk to herself. She was very selfless in that way, guided by a love that was supreme and boundless.

The Torah portion this week covers Moses and Aaron’s early cajoling of Pharaoh to let the children of Israel go out from slavery to freedom. The commentators note that it is a bit strange that God chose Moses to confront Pharoah despite the fact that he claims lo ish devarim anochi - “oh please God, I am not a man of words”, and yet God selects Moses anyhow. God nonetheless also selects Aaron to go with him, even though God only appeared to Moses. Aaron can only speak to Pharaoh removed once from the source, as a second-hand witness. This creates a strange tension in the text about who and how and whether the word of God can be properly conveyed to Pharaoh, either by Moses, or by Aaron. 

The eminent bible scholar and Cambridge PhD in English literature Aviva Zornberg explains this as a problem with the precision and conveyance of language. She writes: “But the problem of language is given great resonance: there is no escape from the imperative of language, because only he has seen and heard. The burden of revelation lies directly on him: only he can speak of what he knows, This means a project of translation: he must make God’s words heard by others. To speak always means to translate, to transform; even the most faithful translations are betrayals: il traductore e traditore - to translate is to betray. Human speech represents; it images. None can, none may give God utterance. Oh, word, word, word that I lack!”

<end quote>


This is a lovely reflection of both Moses’ task in conveying to Pharaoh the right words that God desires, and the great lifes work of Marilyn Stern in crafting the right words and instilling others to craft the right words, and to read the right words, and to love the right words.


Marilyn loved all literature, and the five books of moses are of course the preferred text of the Jewish people for reflection and meaning. Marilyn’s favorite works were Shakespeare, though, so I will leave her, and us, with this small piece from my favorite William Shakespeare play, Hamlet, in a scene in the second act where he meets again with his friends Rosencrans and Guildenstern.


Hamlet says, in greeting Rosencrantz, the following:

That you must teach me. But let me conjure you by the rights
of our fellowship, by the consonancy of our youth, by the
obligation of our ever-preserved love, and by what more dear a
better proposer could charge you withal, be even and direct with
me,

This sums up our dear Miri Elka Bat Moshe Aharon v’Kunyah, Marilyn Stern, quite succinctly: a teacher, someone who was wonderfully precise and direct, and most of all, one abounding of an ever-preserved love for her family and her friends. May we learn from her example, and may she be bound up in the bond of life.

0 Comments
<<Previous
Forward>>

    Divrei Torah

    A 'Dvar Torah'; literally a 'word of Torah', is an explanation of a verse or a concept from the Torah. Enjoy Rabbi Goodman's takes on the weekly Torah portion, the holidays, or a matter of Jewish ethics here.

    All work is copyrighted, but may be used with citation or attribution.

    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

    Archives

    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    January 2026
    October 2025
    September 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    April 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    August 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    March 2024
    January 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    September 2021
    March 2021
    September 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    October 2016
    April 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    July 2014
    April 2013

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly